Fractional CMO

Short answer: A fractional CMO RFP should be short: your business context, the problem, scope, hours, budget range, decision rights, success measures, timeline and a few focused questions. Send it to three to five shortlisted people, score replies against weighted criteria, and pay for any detailed strategy work. Long procurement-style RFPs tend to deter experienced independents.

How to write a fractional CMO RFP: template and scorecard, cover

Some companies must run a formal process to appoint a fractional CMO: a board wants evidence of comparison, procurement requires it, or the founders simply want to be fair and thorough. A request for proposal can help, but the standard version can backfire. Fractional CMOs are mostly independents or tiny firms who do not have bid teams, and a 30-page document with a demand for a free strategy will push the best of them away. This guide shows you how to write a short RFP that good candidates will answer, gives you a template, and explains how to compare replies without being fooled by the best-looking deck.

Do you need an RFP to hire a fractional CMO?

An RFP is useful when several people need to agree on a decision, when you must show a fair comparison, or when you do not know how candidates differ and want to see them answer the same questions.

It is usually unnecessary when you already have a trusted referral, when the founder alone is deciding and when your scope is still unclear. If you do not know the problem yet, an RFP will produce polished guesses. In that case, pay one candidate for a short diagnostic, then decide. The job description template may also be enough for a less formal search.

Remember that a fractional CMO is a senior person who will work closely with you, not a commodity vendor. Chemistry, candour and judgement matter as much as the document. An RFP can narrow the field, but it cannot make the decision for you.

You are still your own head of marketing. What happens when a founder still runs marketing, and how a part-time CMO takes over strategy, budget, team and reporting. 42 seconds. Narrated with an AI voice. Charts shown are illustrative. See fractional CMO services
Read the transcript

You are still your own head of marketing. Marketing has a budget and agencies. Nobody senior is running it.

Every campaign waits for you. Each agency reports its own numbers. Nobody senior owns the pipeline target.

What you need is a leader, not another vendor.

Senior leadership, part time. One person owns the plan and the number. You get your time back, and marketing gets a leader.

Fractional CMO, with Rahul D Sarker. Book a call at rahuldsarker.co.

What should a fractional CMO RFP include?

Keep the document to about two pages. Copy and edit this.

Request for proposal: fractional CMO

1. About us. What we sell, to whom, in which markets. Revenue range or funding stage. Team size. Current marketing team and agencies. Sales motion.

2. The problem. What we want to change, and why now. What we have tried. What we think the cause is, while recognising that this may be wrong.

3. Scope. What the person will own. What they will not own. Who they will work with.

4. Time and terms. Expected hours a week, location or time zone needs, start date, initial term, review point.

5. Budget. Retainer range, plus the size of the marketing budget they would manage.

6. Success measures. What we want to see at 90 days and six months.

7. Information available. What data we can share under NDA, and how to ask for it.

8. Questions. (See the next section.)

9. Process and timeline. Reply date, call dates, decision date, and who decides. How we will handle confidential information and whether any part of the work is paid.

10. Format. A reply of no more than three pages. No custom strategy deck required.

What questions should a fractional CMO RFP ask?

A small number of questions, answered well, tells you more than a long questionnaire. Eight is plenty.

  1. Describe a similar problem you have handled. What did you do first, and what changed?
  2. Based only on this document, what do you suspect is going on, and what would you need to check?
  3. What would your first 30 days look like?
  4. What would you expect to stop or change quickly, and what would you leave alone?
  5. How do you work with sales, agencies and a founder? Give an example of a disagreement and how it ended.
  6. How many clients do you have at once, and how would you protect time for us?
  7. Who does the execution? Do you bring a team, or do you work through ours?
  8. What would make you tell us this is the wrong role or the wrong time?

Add two or three questions specific to your situation, such as experience with your sector or a market you plan to enter. Avoid asking candidates to list everything they have ever done. A LinkedIn profile covers that. Our broader interview question list offers more options for later rounds.

How do you score fractional CMO proposals?

Agree the criteria and their weights before reading any replies. Each reviewer should score alone first, then compare. The weights below are a starting point, not a rule.

Example scorecard (score each 1 to 5, then multiply by the weight)
CriterionWeightWhat a strong answer shows
Relevant problems solved25%Specific examples at a similar stage and sales motion, with honest results
Quality of diagnosis20%Good questions and hypotheses, not a confident fix before seeing the data
Commercial focus15%Talks about pipeline, margin and payback, not only activity
Working style and leadership15%Clear examples of working with founders, teams and agencies
Capacity and availability10%A realistic client load, and clarity about hours
Execution model10%Clear about who does the work, and any extra costs
Value for the scope5%Fee fits the hours and scope, with no hidden costs

Price has a low weight on purpose. Compare it once you are sure the scope is equal, because a low fee with few real hours is not cheaper. Adjust the weights if you have a reason.

Should you ask candidates for a free strategy?

The most common RFP mistake is asking for a detailed marketing plan as part of the bid. There are several problems with this.

  • Experienced people often decline. Their time is what they sell, and they have other options.
  • You get guesses. Without your data, any plan is mostly generic, however well presented. You could end up choosing the best presenter.
  • It raises fairness and IP questions. If you use someone's ideas without hiring them, you damage your reputation, and you may have legal questions to answer.

Better alternatives:

  • Ask for a hypothesis and first steps in a page or two. That shows thinking without giving away the work.
  • Run a working session with finalists on real numbers, and pay for the time if it runs long.
  • Commission a paid diagnostic from your preferred candidate, with the fee credited to the retainer if you continue. You test the relationship on real work and you keep the output, whether or not you go further.

How to run the process in three weeks

A long process loses people, because independent leaders fill their calendars quickly. This plan suits most companies:

Week 1. Agree the problem, budget and decision-makers internally. Build a shortlist of three to five people from referrals, your investors, founder communities and LinkedIn. Contact each personally before sending the RFP, as a cold document gets ignored. Have the NDA ready.

Week 2. Allow about a week for replies, and answer questions openly. Score replies individually, then together. Choose two or three for calls.

Week 3. Hold a 45-minute call with each finalist, and include the person who would work with them most. Discuss real numbers under NDA if you can. Take references for your preferred candidate, asking what changed and what could have gone better. Make the decision, then move to the contract.

Always tell unsuccessful candidates promptly, with a short honest reason. The fractional world is small, and you may want to work with them later. Once you have decided, finalise the terms using our fractional CMO contract template.

Red flags in RFP replies

Watch for these when reviewing responses.

  • Certainty without data. "We will double your pipeline in six months" before seeing anything is a sales line, not a diagnosis.
  • No questions. Strong candidates ask about your numbers, team and past attempts.
  • Examples with no detail. Big claims about past clients, with no explanation of the starting point, their own role or the timeframe.
  • A hidden agency. A "fractional CMO" who mainly exists to sell an agency's retainer. This can be fine if it is declared, but you should know about it.
  • An unrealistic client load. Someone with many clients and few hours left may not be able to deliver for you.
  • Vague execution model. You cannot tell who will do the work or what it will cost.
  • Agreement with everything in your brief. A good leader challenges at least part of your thinking.

For a broader list, see how to choose a fractional CMO. After selection, the mandate before day one will help you start well.

Before you send it: a final check

Read your RFP as a busy, senior candidate would, and check these points:

  • Is the problem specific enough for someone to tell whether they can help?
  • Is the budget realistic for the scope? Compare it against typical structures on our fractional CMO cost page.
  • Does anyone with authority stand behind this? Name the sponsor.
  • Can it be answered in an hour or two?
  • Have you explained what happens next, and when?
  • Have you avoided asking for a free plan?
  • Have you offered an NDA, if real numbers are needed?
  • Are all reviewers in agreement about the criteria and the weights?

If most of these are a yes, you have a document that good candidates will actually want to answer. If you find you cannot state the problem clearly, that is useful to know too: start with a diagnostic, and return to the RFP when you know what you are buying.

FAQ

Three to five is usually enough. More than that adds work for you and lowers the chance that strong candidates will bother to respond. Spend your time building a good shortlist from trusted referrals.

Yes, at least a range. Without it, you will get replies you cannot afford and scopes you cannot compare. Candidates can then explain what is possible within your range.

They can, but ask who the actual named person is, how many hours they will give, whether other agency services are bundled and how conflicts are handled when the same firm wants to sell execution.

For a short call, no. For anything that resembles real strategy work, yes. A small paid working session or a diagnostic gets you better output and a truer sense of how the person works.

Read this article on your favourite platform

Ready to build the system?

If this describes your funnel, a 30-minute call will find where the constraint sits in your own numbers and what it would take to fix it.

It starts with a 30-minute call. Pick a time below.

Prefer email?